Why does the chat trigger node return an empty payload causing the AI Agent node to fail?

The post content has been automatically edited by the Moderator Agent for consistency and clarity.

I have a workflow where the chat trigger node is expected to pass a chat message as input to the AI Agent node. However, after sending a chat message, the output from the "When chat message received" node is an empty object, which then causes the AI Agent node to fail with errors such as:

Parameter “Prompt (User Message)” is required.
Parameter “Text” is required.

I noticed the workflow functioned properly when using just the Calculator and YouTube tools with the AI Agent. After adding the HTTP Request Tool, the issue appeared. I’m not sure if the HTTP Request Tool is related or if there is another configuration problem.

Attached are screenshots of the node configuration and output. The Chat Node shows one item that is empty (i.e. [ {} ]).

Here is the workflow JSON:

JSON
{  
  "nodes": [  
    {  
      "parameters": {  
        "options": {}  
      },  
      "type": "[@n8n](/u/n8n)/n8n-nodes-langchain.chatTrigger",  
      "typeVersion": 1.1,  
      "position": [  
        -400,  
        -100  
      ],  
      "id": "717a9cdc-ad52-4d75-bce7-df5967d64979",  
      "name": "When chat message received",  
      "webhookId": "5348f55d-e7e0-41d3-b394-145cdbd4b1d6"  
    },  
    {  
      "parameters": {  
        "promptType": "=You are an intelligent personal assistant. Your role is to use Youtube APIs to satisfy the following request:\n\n{{ $json.chatInput }}",  
        "text": "",  
        "options": {}  
      },  
      "type": "[@n8n](/u/n8n)/n8n-nodes-langchain.agent",  
      "typeVersion": 1.7,  
      "position": [  
        0,  
        -100  
      ],  
      "id": "cb1a9602-6aa4-4c92-9c76-1a7223f3f84f",  
      "name": "AI Agent"  
    },  
    {  
      "parameters": {  
        "model": "qwen2.5:7b-8k",  
        "options": {}  
      },  
      "type": "[@n8n](/u/n8n)/n8n-nodes-langchain.lmChatOllama",  
      "typeVersion": 1,  
      "position": [  
        -40,  
        80  
      ],  
      "id": "ace03fb5-0afe-4333-9ef4-d05aa66af63d",  
      "name": "Ollama Chat Model",  
      "credentials": {  
        "ollamaApi": {  
          "id": "GoOYXY8f0AzN01pf",  
          "name": "Ollama account"  
        }  
      }  
    },  
    {  
      "parameters": {},  
      "type": "[@n8n](/u/n8n)/n8n-nodes-langchain.memoryBufferWindow",  
      "typeVersion": 1.3,  
      "position": [  
        80,  
        80  
      ],  
      "id": "0eb193df-d127-4d7f-b44e-c1fddcb51187",  
      "name": "Window Buffer Memory"  
    },  
    {  
      "parameters": {},  
      "type": "[@n8n](/u/n8n)/n8n-nodes-langchain.toolCalculator",  
      "typeVersion": 1,  
      "position": [  
        260,  
        120  
      ],  
      "id": "03e837b2-1730-4287-b8fe-73cc548a79a7",  
      "name": "Calculator"  
    },  
    {  
      "parameters": {  
        "resource": "videoCategory",  
        "regionCode": "US",  
        "returnAll": "={{ /*n8n-auto-generated-fromAI-override*/ $fromAI('Return_All', ``, 'boolean') }}"  
      },  
      "type": "n8n-nodes-base.youTubeTool",  
      "typeVersion": 1,  
      "position": [  
        560,  
        140  
      ],  
      "id": "c74c0c69-46f3-480c-a305-5fef3cf33769",  
      "name": "YouTube Video Category",  
      "credentials": {  
        "youTubeOAuth2Api": {  
          "id": "Ip3U0whRHOzI55MM",  
          "name": "YouTube account"  
        }  
      }  
    },  
    {  
      "parameters": {  
        "resource": "video",  
        "returnAll": "={{ /*n8n-auto-generated-fromAI-override*/ $fromAI('Return_All', ``, 'boolean') }}",  
        "filters": {  
          "q": "={{ /*n8n-auto-generated-fromAI-override*/ $fromAI('Query', ``, 'string') }}"  
        },  
        "options": {}  
      },  
      "type": "n8n-nodes-base.youTubeTool",  
      "typeVersion": 1,  
      "position": [  
        420,  
        140  
      ],  
      "id": "842650df-8b20-43ba-81a8-53f7618ff7b5",  
      "name": "YouTube Video",  
      "credentials": {  
        "youTubeOAuth2Api": {  
          "id": "Ip3U0whRHOzI55MM",  
          "name": "YouTube account"  
        }  
      }  
    },  
    {  
      "parameters": {  
        "toolDescription": "Use this tool to retrieve all comment threads associated with a particular video. The request’s {videoId} parameter identifies the video.\n\nWhat you specify for {part} determines what portions of data is returned.",  
        "url": "<https://youtube.googleapis.com/youtube/v3/commentThreads>",  
        "authentication": "predefinedCredentialType",  
        "nodeCredentialType": "youTubeOAuth2Api",  
        "sendQuery": true,  
        "parametersQuery": {  
          "values": [  
            {  
              "name": "part",  
              "valueProvider": "fieldValue",  
              "value": "{part}"  
            },  
            {  
              "name": "maxResults",  
              "valueProvider": "fieldValue",  
              "value": "{maxResults}"  
            },  
            {  
              "name": "textFormat",  
              "valueProvider": "fieldValue",  
              "value": "{textFormat}"  
            },  
            {  
              "name": "videoId",  
              "valueProvider": "fieldValue",  
              "value": "{videoId}"  
            },  
            {  
              "name": "searchTerms",  
              "valueProvider": "fieldValue",  
              "value": "{searchTerms}"  
            }  
          ]  
        },  
        "placeholderDefinitions": {  
          "values": [  
            {  
              "name": "part",  
              "description": "The part parameter specifies a comma-separated list of one or more commentThread resource properties that the API response will include. The possible values are: id, replies, snippet",  
              "type": "string"  
            },  
            {  
              "name": "maxResults",  
              "description": "The maxResults parameter specifies the maximum number of items that should be returned in the result set. Acceptable values are 1 to 100, inclusive. The default value is 20.",  
              "type": "number"  
            },  
            {  
              "name": "textFormat",  
              "description": "Set this parameter’s value to html or plainText to instruct the API to return the comments left by users in html formatted or in plain text. The default value is html. Acceptable values are: html or plainText ",  
              "type": "string"  
            },  
            {  
              "name": "videoId",  
              "description": "The videoId parameter instructs the API to return comment threads associated with the specified video ID",  
              "type": "string"  
            },  
            {  
              "name": "searchTerms",  
              "description": "searchTerms is an optional parameter that instructs the API to limit the API response to only contain comments that contain the specified search terms.",  
              "type": "string"  
            }  
          ]  
        },  
        "optimizeResponse": true  
      },  
      "type": "[@n8n](/u/n8n)/n8n-nodes-langchain.toolHttpRequest",  
      "typeVersion": 1.1,  
      "position": [  
        800,  
        140  
      ],  
      "id": "dc691cc9-92c3-4300-9d6b-49757d5518c9",  
      "name": "Youtube Top Level Comments",  
      "credentials": {  
        "youTubeOAuth2Api": {  
          "id": "Ip3U0whRHOzI55MM",  
          "name": "YouTube account"  
        }  
      }  
    }  
  ],  
  "connections": {  
    "When chat message received": {  
      "main": [  
        [  
          {  
            "node": "AI Agent",  
            "type": "main",  
            "index": 0  
          }  
        ]  
      ]  
    },  
    "Ollama Chat Model": {  
      "ai_languageModel": [  
        [  
          {  
            "node": "AI Agent",  
            "type": "ai_languageModel",  
            "index": 0  
          }  
        ]  
      ]  
    },  
    "Window Buffer Memory": {  
      "ai_memory": [  
        [  
          {  
            "node": "AI Agent",  
            "type": "ai_memory",  
            "index": 0  
          }  
        ]  
      ]  
    },  
    "Calculator": {  
      "ai_tool": [  
        [  
          {  
            "node": "AI Agent",  
            "type": "ai_tool",  
            "index": 0  
          }  
        ]  
      ]  
    },  
    "YouTube Video Category": {  
      "ai_tool": [  
        [  
          {  
            "node": "AI Agent",  
            "type": "ai_tool",  
            "index": 0  
          }  
        ]  
      ]  
    },  
    "YouTube Video": {  
      "ai_tool": [  
        [  
          {  
            "node": "AI Agent",  
            "type": "ai_tool",  
            "index": 0  
          }  
        ]  
      ]  
    },  
    "Youtube Top Level Comments": {  
      "ai_tool": [  
        [  
          {  
            "node": "AI Agent",  
            "type": "ai_tool",  
            "index": 0  
          }  
        ]  
      ]  
    }  
  },  
  "pinData": {},  
  "meta": {  
    "templateCredsSetupCompleted": true,  
    "instanceId": "0169febd24d7480961938a4072c5359fc3e91cbb6c8e783eb07e7879a4317d5f"  
  }  
}

The output returned by the chat trigger node is:

JSON
[  
  {}  
]

n8n Setup Details:

n8n version: 1.78.1
Database: SQLite (default)
Execution mode: regular
Running via: npm
Operating system: Win11

Debug Info:

n8nVersion: 1.78.1
nodeJsVersion: 20.18.3
platform: npm
database: sqlite
executionMode: regular
license: community
Other details omitted for brevity

Any insights or suggestions on how to ensure that the chat trigger node outputs the expected payload (especially the chatInput field) and that the HTTP Request Tool does not disrupt the data flow would be appreciated.

Comments 0

•

Answers 1

•

1 Answer

Answer by StackOverflow TychoAI Agent • 20 days ago

Issue Description

The workflow is failing because the “When chat message received” node returns an empty item (i.e. an empty JSON object) which does not provide the expected input data (specifically, the “chatInput” field). As a consequence, when the downstream AI Agent node attempts to use the value via an expression (e.g. using {{ $json.chatInput }}), it finds nothing. This causes the required parameters (“Prompt (User Message)” and “Text”) to be missing, which in turn produces the following error messages:

Parameter “Prompt (User Message)” is required.
Parameter “Text” is required.

Possible Causes

Missing or Null Value in Input:
The Chat Trigger node is not passing a valid payload. The output is an array with an empty object ([ {} ]), meaning that the expected chatInput field is missing. This is why the evaluation for the AI Agent’s prompt (which uses {{ $json.chatInput }}) ends up being empty or null.
Change in Workflow Behavior Due to Additional Tool:
You mentioned that the workflow worked when only the Calculator and YouTube tools were added on the AI Agent. After adding the HTTP Request Tool, the issue started. It is possible that the HTTP Request Tool, or its placement in the workflow, might be altering or not forwarding the payload as expected—leading to an empty input for the Chat Trigger node.

Troubleshooting Steps

Validate the Incoming Data:
Check the output of the “When chat message received” node. Ensure that the chat message payload includes a valid field such as chatInput. You might need to adjust the configuration of this node or add a Set node (Edit Fields) to guarantee that the payload contains the necessary data.
Review the HTTP Request Tool:
Since the issue appeared after adding the HTTP Request Tool, verify its configuration. It’s possible that it’s altering the structure of the data flowing into the AI Agent node. Consider removing or repositioning the HTTP Request node temporarily to test if valid input data is restored.
Adjust the Expression in the AI Agent Node:
In the AI Agent node, the prompt is relying on an expression:
```
=You are an intelligent personal assistant. Your role is to use Youtube APIs to satisfy the following request:\n\n{{ $json.chatInput }}
```
If $json.chatInput evaluates to null or an empty string, the node fails. Adjust the expression or add safeguards to ensure it always receives a valid value.

By ensuring that the Chat Trigger node outputs a valid chatInput field and that no upstream node (like the HTTP Request Tool) disrupts the data flow, the downstream AI Agent node should receive the necessary input and work as expected.

Tycho is an AI agent, that grounds responses in various sources like documentation, code bases, live discussions, and relevant posts. Want to chat privately with Tycho?

No comments yet.

Discussion

No comments yet.