What are the differences between .runsettings and xunit.runner.json for configuring xUnit.net tests?

Below is an explanation in markdown:

---

Overview

xUnit.net supports two configuration files when running tests:

• .runsettings
• xunit.runner.json

Each file serves a different purpose and is read by different parts of the test ecosystem.

---

.runsettings

• Purpose:
  The .runsettings file is intended for configuring the Visual Studio Test Platform. It is a generic test configuration file that can affect many test frameworks (not just xUnit.net).

• Usage:
  Use .runsettings if you want to configure settings that apply to the test host, such as:

  • Test execution parameters (e.g., test timeouts, data collectors)
  • Environment variables
  • Configuration for parallel test execution (as interpreted by the test platform)

• Limitations for xUnit:
  Because it is generic, .runsettings does not expose all xUnit-specific options. It is focused on settings that the Visual Studio Test Runner understands.

---

xunit.runner.json

• Purpose:
  The xunit.runner.json file is specifically designed to configure the xUnit.net runner. It supports xUnit-specific settings beyond what the generic test platform supports.

• Usage:
  Use xunit.runner.json to configure details such as:

  • xUnit.net’s internal diagnostic settings
  • Specific parallelization behavior tuned for xUnit.net
  • Other xUnit-specific run-time settings that the test platform does not cover

• Flexibility:
  Because it’s tailored to xUnit.net, configuration options are more specific to the framework’s own execution model.

---

Why Different Settings Are Available

The two files are not redundant because they are consumed by different parts of the test infrastructure:

• .runsettings is for the outer layer of test execution managed by Visual Studio’s testing tools and dotnet test. It handles settings common to all test frameworks.

• xunit.runner.json is read by the xUnit.net-specific runner (i.e., the code that actually discovers and executes tests written with xUnit.net) and thus can support settings that are unique to the xUnit.net framework.

---

When to Use Which Flavor

• Use .runsettings when:

  • You need to configure aspects of the test host that affect all test frameworks.
  • You require settings like test host parameters, environmental setups, or cross-framework configuration that the Visual Studio Test Platform uses.

• Use xunit.runner.json when:

  • You need to tweak behavior that is specific to xUnit.net.
  • You want to adjust settings such as xUnit.net’s internal diagnostics, parallelization peculiarities, or other framework-specific behaviors.

• Both Can Be Used Together:
  If you require both generic test platform settings and additional xUnit.net-specific options, you can include both files in your project. The test platform will process the .runsettings file, while the xUnit.net runner will load the settings in xunit.runner.json.

---

This separation of concerns allows for cleaner configuration management: the generic settings that affect test execution broadly are separated from the xUnit-specific settings that fine-tune the xUnit test runner's behavior.