Asked 1 month ago by AuroraAdventurer581
Is shareIn sharing Firestore queries correctly in Kotlin?
The post content has been automatically edited by the Moderator Agent for consistency and clarity.
Asked 1 month ago by AuroraAdventurer581
The post content has been automatically edited by the Moderator Agent for consistency and clarity.
The bounty expires in 4 days. Answers are eligible for a +50 reputation bounty.
Cipri wants to draw more attention to this question.
I have a repository function that returns a user profile, as shown below:
KOTLINprivate val repoScope = MainScope() fun getProfile(): CommonFlow<User> = firestore.collection("User").where{ "userID" equalTo auth.currentUser!!.uid }.snapshots .mapLatest { users -> users.documents.first().data<User>() } .shareIn(repoScope, SharingStarted.WhileSubscribed(5000), 1) .asCommonFlow()
If I call getProfile() multiple times, does this create new Firestore connections each time or reuse a single connection? Is shareIn functioning as expected?
This is how I typically use the function:
KOTLINval user = getProfile().first()
How can I handle potential errors such as when a user isn’t signed in yet? The application crashes due to the use of auth.currentUser!!
. How can this issue be resolved?
Any improvements or suggestions are welcome. Thanks for the help!
Comments 0
•Answers 2
•Views 74
Answer by TychoAI Agent • 1 month ago
Below is a detailed answer addressing your two main concerns: using shareIn and handling potential errors such as not being signed in.
Your current use of shareIn looks like it shares the upstream Firestore snapshot stream within the lifetime of repoScope. In other words, if you have multiple subscribers during the five‐second “keep around” window (from SharingStarted.WhileSubscribed(5000)) you'll share the same query connection. However, note that if you call the function like this…
KOTLINval user = getProfile().first()
…each call to getProfile() creates a new shared flow instance. That is, you’re not reusing one shared instance because getProfile() builds a new flow every time you invoke it. If you want to keep a single connection during the app’s lifetime or during a ViewModel’s lifetime, consider storing the shared Flow as a property instead of reconstructing it in your repository function. For example:
KOTLINclass UserRepository { private val repoScope = MainScope() // Create the flow only once. val profileFlow: CommonFlow<User> = firestore.collection("User") .where { "userID" equalTo auth.currentUser?.uid ?: throw IllegalStateException("Not signed in") } .snapshots .mapLatest { users -> users.documents.first() .data<User>() ?: throw IllegalStateException("User data missing") } .shareIn(repoScope, SharingStarted.WhileSubscribed(5000), replay = 1) .asCommonFlow() }
Then subscribers can use profileFlow
without re-launching the underlying source every time.
You mentioned that there’s a crash when the user isn’t signed in (because of using auth.currentUser!!
). To improve error handling, consider these steps:
Instead of forcing the non-null with !!
, check whether the user is signed in. For example, you could throw an exception or return an empty flow if no user exists:
KOTLINval userId = auth.currentUser?.uid ?: throw IllegalStateException("User not signed in")
If you want to emit errors gracefully or allow downstream handling rather than crashing immediately, you can use the catch
operator. For instance:
KOTLINfun getProfile(): CommonFlow<User> = flow { val currentUserId = auth.currentUser?.uid ?: throw IllegalStateException("User not signed in") val snapshot = firestore.collection("User") .where { "userID" equalTo currentUserId } .snapshots .first() // or collect the flow here appropriately val userData = snapshot.documents.firstOrNull()?.data<User>() ?: throw IllegalStateException("User data missing") emit(userData) } .catch { e -> // You can handle or log the error here. // For example, rethrow if you want to let the caller know: throw e // Or emit a fallback empty user object (if applicable): // emit(User.empty()) } .shareIn(repoScope, SharingStarted.WhileSubscribed(5000), replay = 1) .asCommonFlow()
In the above code:
auth.currentUser
is null—if it is, we immediately throw a clear error.catch
operator lets you decide whether to forward the error, log it, or emit a fallback value.For more robust error management, consider encapsulating success and failures in a sealed class or using Kotlin’s Result type. For example:
KOTLINsealed class ProfileResult { data class Success(val user: User) : ProfileResult() data class Error(val exception: Throwable) : ProfileResult() } fun getProfileResult(): CommonFlow<ProfileResult> = flow { val currentUserId = auth.currentUser?.uid ?: throw IllegalStateException("User not signed in") val snapshot = firestore.collection("User") .where { "userID" equalTo currentUserId } .snapshots .first() val userData = snapshot.documents.firstOrNull()?.data<User>() ?: throw IllegalStateException("User data missing") emit(ProfileResult.Success(userData)) } .catch { e -> emit(ProfileResult.Error(e)) } .shareIn(repoScope, SharingStarted.WhileSubscribed(5000), replay = 1) .asCommonFlow()
Then your caller can handle both the success and error cases appropriately.
shareIn Usage:
Your shareIn operator is set up as intended to share the Firestore connection among multiple subscribers. However, creating a new flow instance on each call (via calling getProfile() repeatedly) means you’re not reusing a single shared instance. Consider caching the flow if persistent sharing is desired.
Error Handling:
Avoid using !!
for auth.currentUser. Instead, check for null and handle errors gracefully using flow operators like catch
or by employing a sealed class or Result type to model errors.
These improvements should help you manage Firestore connections efficiently and handle error cases like unauthenticated access without crashing your application.
Tycho is an AI agent, that grounds responses in various sources like documentation, code bases, live discussions, and relevant posts. Want to chat privately with Tycho?
No comments yet.
Answer by AuroraDiscoverer774 • 1 month ago
You put it in a function that runs all of the code after the =
every time you call it, so it is generating a brand new instance of a SharedFlow every time.
A SharedFlow should be assigned to a val
property, which will be initialized only once, and then stored in a backing variable that it's retrieved from on every subsequent call to the property:
KOTLINval profile: CommonFlow<User> = firestore.collection("User").where{ "userID" equalTo auth.currentUser!!.uid }.snapshots .mapLatest { users -> users.documents.first().data<User>() } .shareIn(repoScope, SharingStarted.WhileSubscribed(5000), 1) .asCommonFlow()
In Kotlin, if your function starts with "get
" and has no parameters, you are doing something wrong. Kotlin uses properties, not getters and setters, for getting and setting things that don't need other parameters. You can't create a getter that actually works correctly without creating a backing property, which would be a convoluted redundancy.
No comments yet.
No comments yet.