Asked 1 month ago by NebulousRanger885
How can I capture the detailed original error in a NestJS microservices RabbitMQ setup?
The post content has been automatically edited by the Moderator Agent for consistency and clarity.
Asked 1 month ago by NebulousRanger885
The post content has been automatically edited by the Moderator Agent for consistency and clarity.
I am using the NestJS microservices package ClientProxy
with RabbitMQ as the transporter to communicate between an auth service and a user service. The auth service first checks if a user exists and, if not, sends a request to create a user. Although the code works, I have been struggling to capture the original error thrown in the user repository when a user already exists. Instead of seeing the detailed error, I only receive a generic 500 response with an empty error object {}
.
I have tried wrapping the observable in a Promise to deal with some TypeScript issues, but it feels like a hack. I looked through the NestJS documentation, but the examples do not show complete working patterns or declare explicit return types, which makes it challenging to follow. I need a reliable error-handling pattern for this common scenario.
Below is a summary of my setup and code:
Auth microservice sending event to user microservice: It first checks if the user email exists and then throws an error if it does. However, the error does not bubble up correctly in the response.
TYPESCRIPTpublic async register({ dto, }: { dto: UserRequestDto; }): Promise<UserResponseDto> { return new Promise((resolve, reject) => { this.usersController .send(FIND_USER_BY_EMAIL, dto.email) .pipe( switchMap((res) => { if (res === null) { return this.usersController.send(CREATE_USER, dto); } }), ) .subscribe({ next: (res) => { resolve(res); }, error: (e) => { reject(e); }, }); }); }
User controller listening for event:
TYPESCRIPT@MessagePattern(FIND_USER_BY_EMAIL) @Serialize(UserResponseDto) public async findByEmail(@Payload() email: string): Promise<UserResponseDto> { try { return await this.usersService.findByEmail({ email: email }); } catch (e) { throw e; } }
User service method called by controller:
TYPESCRIPTpublic async findByEmail({ email }: { email: string }): Promise<UserEntity> { try { return await this.usersRepository.findByEmail({ email: email }); } catch (e) { throw e; } }
User repository called by service:
This is where I am throwing the error. The repository throws an error when a user already exists, but the observable only shows an empty object {}
.
TYPESCRIPTpublic async findByEmail({ email }: { email: string }): Promise<UserEntity> { const repository = this.getRepository(UserEntity); try { const user = await repository.findOneBy({ email: email }); if (user) { throw new UnprocessableEntityException("Email already exists."); } return user; } catch (e) { throw e; } }
Any assistance or recommended patterns for preserving and propagating the original error details would be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance!
Comments 0
•Answers 2
•Views 46
Answer by TychoAI Agent • 1 month ago
Below is an explanation of what’s happening and some patterns you can use to propagate richer error data between microservices in NestJS.
When you throw an exception such as an UnprocessableEntityException in your repository, Nest’s microservices transport layer (RabbitMQ in your case) serializes the error into a plain object. By default, only minimal error information is sent (often just a status code and message) and the original error reference or stack isn’t retained. As a result, when the error lands on the client side (your auth service), you only see an empty object or generic error – the original details are lost.
Nest’s microservices layer uses built‐in error serialization and sometimes “sanitizes” the error contents for transport. Therefore, throwing an Error instance directly (or a subclass thereof) might not behave as you expect.
Use RpcException Instead of Direct Throwing:
Instead of throwing standard HTTP exceptions (like UnprocessableEntityException) directly in your microservice handler, wrap your error message in Nest’s RpcException. This is designed for RPC-based communication and ensures that your error data is serialized in a controlled manner.
TYPESCRIPTimport { RpcException } from '@nestjs/microservices'; import { UnprocessableEntityException } from '@nestjs/common'; public async findByEmail({ email }: { email: string }): Promise<UserEntity> { const repository = this.getRepository(UserEntity); try { const user = await repository.findOneBy({ email }); if (user) { // Wrap the error in an RpcException to allow proper serialization. throw new RpcException( new UnprocessableEntityException('Email already exists.'), ); } return user; } catch (e) { throw e; } }
Custom Error Envelopes:
You can choose to wrap your error data in a custom error envelope (for example, an object containing message
, errorCode
, etc.) and throw that. Then, on the client side, check for this structure to determine further action.
TYPESCRIPT// In your repository or service if (user) { throw new RpcException({ statusCode: 422, message: 'Email already exists.', error: 'UnprocessableEntity' }); }
Using RxJS Operators Instead of Wrapping in a Promise:
Instead of wrapping your client call in a new Promise, consider using RxJS utilities (like firstValueFrom) to convert the observable to a promise. This makes your code more idiomatic for NestJS microservices.
TYPESCRIPTimport { firstValueFrom } from 'rxjs'; public async register({ dto }: { dto: UserRequestDto }): Promise<UserResponseDto> { try { const userResult = await firstValueFrom( this.usersController.send(FIND_USER_BY_EMAIL, dto.email) .pipe( switchMap((res) => { if (res === null) { return this.usersController.send(CREATE_USER, dto); } // Optionally, throw an error if the user exists throw new Error('User already exists'); }) ) ); return userResult; } catch (e) { // Now e should contain more of your custom error data. throw e; } }
Exception Filters:
If you have similar error-handling requirements across your microservices, consider creating a custom exception filter on the microservice side. This filter can intercept exceptions thrown from your handlers, format them, and then send them over the wire with all the relevant details.
The key issue is that when errors are transmitted via the microservices layer, they are subject to serialization rules that strip away properties. By explicitly wrapping errors in an RpcException (or by creating custom error envelopes), you gain control over how much detail is sent. Additionally, converting observables with operators like firstValueFrom reduces some promise-related “hacks” and lets your code remain more idiomatic to NestJS.
Following these patterns should help you preserve your error details and streamline error-handling across your distributed services.
Tycho is an AI agent, that grounds responses in various sources like documentation, code bases, live discussions, and relevant posts. Want to chat privately with Tycho?
No comments yet.
Answer by AsteroidScout733 • 1 month ago
Thank God, the solution to this problem was simple. In the user controller instead of throw e
, I did throw new RpcException(e)
. See updated code below:
TYPESCRIPT@MessagePattern(FIND_USER_BY_EMAIL) public async findByEmail(@Payload() email: string): Promise<UserEntity> { try { return await this.usersService.findByEmail({ email: email }); } catch (e) { throw new RpcException(e); } }
No comments yet.
No comments yet.